Amazing Monster Showdown - Round One

[The Drunken Severed Head]

I would add a bout for my favorite character, but we all know that Coffin Joe has no equal.

I'm stunned that you'd admit that Coffin Joe isn't equal to the classic monsters in this list! What candor! 

[Nicole]

I'm stunned that you'd admit that Coffin Joe isn't equal to the classic monsters in this list! What candor! 

Yes, I know it takes a lot of guts to admit that Coffin Joe is equal to nothing, and superior to everything, but someone had to say it, you know?

Now for my next pick from among these other, vastly inferior creatures!

Godzilla vs. Gamera +1
Teenage Werewolf vs The Hideous Sun Demon -1

Ymir vs. the colossal man (AKA the colossal beast)  4
Gort vs. Martians from War of the Worlds  3
Beast From The Haunted Cave vs. "Beulah" from IT CONQUERED THE WORLD 2
Tarantula Vs. The Giant Mantis 5
The Mole People vs. The Morlocks  3
Teenage Werewolf vs The Hideous Sun Demon  1
Godzilla vs. Gamera  4
Dracula vs. Nosferatu  4
The Thing from Another World vs. It the Terror from Beyond Space  2
King Kong vs. The Blob  3
The Abominable Dr. Phibes vs. The Phantom of the Opera  5
Blacula vs. Blackenstein  4
The Monster on the Campus vs. Teenage Frankenstein  2

[The Drunken Severed Head]

Plus one for Cave Beast vs. Beulah
Minus one for Teenage Werewolf vs. Sun Demon (OUT)

Ymir vs. the colossal man (AKA the colossal beast)  4
Gort vs. Martians from War of the Worlds  3
Beast From The Haunted Cave vs. "Beulah" from IT CONQUERED THE WORLD 3
Tarantula Vs. The Giant Mantis 5
The Mole People vs. The Morlocks  3
Godzilla vs. Gamera  4
Dracula vs. Nosferatu  4
The Thing from Another World vs. It the Terror from Beyond Space  2
King Kong vs. The Blob  3
The Abominable Dr. Phibes vs. The Phantom of the Opera  5
Blacula vs. Blackenstein  4
The Monster on the Campus vs. Teenage Frankenstein  2

[drgangrene]

Blackula vs. Blackenstein +1
Beast From The Haunted Cave vs. "Beulah" from IT CONQUERED THE WORLD  -1

Ymir vs. the colossal man (AKA the colossal beast)  4
Gort vs. Martians from War of the Worlds  3
Beast From The Haunted Cave vs. "Beulah" from IT CONQUERED THE WORLD 2
Tarantula Vs. The Giant Mantis 5
The Mole People vs. The Morlocks  3
Godzilla vs. Gamera  4
Dracula vs. Nosferatu  4
The Thing from Another World vs. It the Terror from Beyond Space  2
King Kong vs. The Blob  3
The Abominable Dr. Phibes vs. The Phantom of the Opera  5
Blacula vs. Blackenstein  5
The Monster on the Campus vs. Teenage Frankenstein  2

[raycastile]

Add:

The Phantom of the Paradise vs Dr. Frank-N-Furter
The Blind Dead vs Gargoyles

Then my +1/-1:

The Monster on the Campus vs. Teenage Frankenstein  -1
The Thing from Another World vs. It the Terror from Beyond Space  +1


Ymir vs. the colossal man (AKA the colossal beast)  4
Gort vs. Martians from War of the Worlds  3
Beast From The Haunted Cave vs. "Beulah" from IT CONQUERED THE WORLD 2
Tarantula Vs. The Giant Mantis 5
The Mole People vs. The Morlocks  3
Godzilla vs. Gamera  4
Dracula vs. Nosferatu  4
The Thing from Another World vs. It the Terror from Beyond Space  3
King Kong vs. The Blob  3
The Abominable Dr. Phibes vs. The Phantom of the Opera  5
Blacula vs. Blackenstein  5
The Monster on the Campus vs. Teenage Frankenstein  1

[The Drunken Severed Head]

Good additions, Raymond!

[drgangrene]

Ray, I agree  - those ARE good matchups! Very cool!

The Abominable Dr. Phibes vs. The Phantom of the Opera +1
Gort vs. Martians from War of the Worlds -1


The Phantom of the Paradise vs Dr. Frank-N-Furter 3
The Blind Dead vs Gargoyles 3
Ymir vs. the colossal man (AKA the colossal beast)  4
Gort vs. Martians from War of the Worlds  2
Beast From The Haunted Cave vs. "Beulah" from IT CONQUERED THE WORLD 2
Tarantula Vs. The Giant Mantis 5
The Mole People vs. The Morlocks  3
Godzilla vs. Gamera  4
Dracula vs. Nosferatu  4
The Thing from Another World vs. It the Terror from Beyond Space  3
King Kong vs. The Blob  3
The Abominable Dr. Phibes vs. The Phantom of the Opera  6
Blacula vs. Blackenstein  5
The Monster on the Campus vs. Teenage Frankenstein  1

[Gary D Macabre]

I'm going to be self serving with this vote

Ymir vs the colossal man/beast +1
Teenage Frankenstein vs. Monster on campus OUT

The Phantom of the Paradise vs Dr. Frank-N-Furter 3
The Blind Dead vs Gargoyles 3
Ymir vs. the colossal man (AKA the colossal beast)  5
Gort vs. Martians from War of the Worlds  2
Beast From The Haunted Cave vs. "Beulah" from IT CONQUERED THE WORLD 2
Tarantula Vs. The Giant Mantis 5
The Mole People vs. The Morlocks  3
Godzilla vs. Gamera  4
Dracula vs. Nosferatu  4
The Thing from Another World vs. It the Terror from Beyond Space  3
King Kong vs. The Blob  3
The Abominable Dr. Phibes vs. The Phantom of the Opera  6
Blacula vs. Blackenstein  5

[ProfGriffin]

Giant from the Unknown...vs. Tabonga (From Hell it Came)

Just tossing it out there...

[brandonslu]

Just adding another battle.

The Giant Claw vs. Mothra.

Daimajin vs. Frankenstein Conquers the World, just keeping it in the homeland.

Gort vs. Martians from War of the Worlds +1
Beast From The Haunted Cave vs. "Beulah" from IT CONQUERED THE WORLD -1

Giant from the Unknown...vs. Tabonga (From Hell it Came) 3
The Phantom of the Paradise vs Dr. Frank-N-Furter 3
The Blind Dead vs Gargoyles 3
Ymir vs. the colossal man (AKA the colossal beast)  5
Gort vs. Martians from War of the Worlds  3
Beast From The Haunted Cave vs. "Beulah" from IT CONQUERED THE WORLD 1
Tarantula Vs. The Giant Mantis 5
The Mole People vs. The Morlocks  3
Godzilla vs. Gamera  4
Dracula vs. Nosferatu  4
The Thing from Another World vs. It the Terror from Beyond Space  3
King Kong vs. The Blob  3
The Abominable Dr. Phibes vs. The Phantom of the Opera  6
Blacula vs. Blackenstein  5

[Nicole]

The Phantom of the Paradise vs Dr. Frank-N-Furter (who wouldn't want to see this one? ) +1
Beast From The Haunted Cave vs. "Beulah" from IT CONQUERED THE WORLD *OUT*

The Giant Claw vs. Mothra 3
Daimajin vs. Frankenstein Conquers the World 3
Giant from the Unknown...vs. Tabonga (From Hell it Came) 3
The Phantom of the Paradise vs Dr. Frank-N-Furter 4
The Blind Dead vs Gargoyles 3
Ymir vs. the colossal man (AKA the colossal beast)  5
Gort vs. Martians from War of the Worlds  3
Tarantula Vs. The Giant Mantis 5
The Mole People vs. The Morlocks  3
Godzilla vs. Gamera  4
Dracula vs. Nosferatu  4
The Thing from Another World vs. It the Terror from Beyond Space  3
King Kong vs. The Blob  3
The Abominable Dr. Phibes vs. The Phantom of the Opera  6
Blacula vs. Blackenstein  5

[drgangrene]

Giant Claw - LOVE it!

The Phantom of the Paradise vs Dr. Frank-N-Furter +1
King Kong vs. The Blob -1
(okay, I know I voted for this one once, but compared to some of the others it just don't cut it!)


The Giant Claw vs. Mothra 3
Daimajin vs. Frankenstein Conquers the World 3
Giant from the Unknown...vs. Tabonga (From Hell it Came) 3
The Phantom of the Paradise vs Dr. Frank-N-Furter 5
The Blind Dead vs Gargoyles 3
Ymir vs. the colossal man (AKA the colossal beast)  5
Gort vs. Martians from War of the Worlds  3
Tarantula Vs. The Giant Mantis 5
The Mole People vs. The Morlocks  3
Godzilla vs. Gamera  4
Dracula vs. Nosferatu  4
The Thing from Another World vs. It the Terror from Beyond Space  3
King Kong vs. The Blob  2
The Abominable Dr. Phibes vs. The Phantom of the Opera  6
Blacula vs. Blackenstein  5

[Gary D Macabre]

Phantom of the paradise and Dr. Frank-N-Furter is a hilarious concept and perhaps could be an early warm up card, but it's just not enough classic monsters to satisfy my monster Kid imagination.  thus it gets my -1

I'm going to throw a bone back to Thing and IT because that really sounds like a Fun and under-rated match-up. +1

The Giant Claw vs. Mothra 3
Daimajin vs. Frankenstein Conquers the World 3
Giant from the Unknown...vs. Tabonga (From Hell it Came) 3
The Phantom of the Paradise vs Dr. Frank-N-Furter 4
The Blind Dead vs Gargoyles 3
Ymir vs. the colossal man (AKA the colossal beast)  5
Gort vs. Martians from War of the Worlds  3
Tarantula Vs. The Giant Mantis 5
The Mole People vs. The Morlocks  3
Godzilla vs. Gamera  4
Dracula vs. Nosferatu  4
The Thing from Another World vs. It the Terror from Beyond Space  4
King Kong vs. The Blob  2
The Abominable Dr. Phibes vs. The Phantom of the Opera  6
Blacula vs. Blackenstein  5

[The Drunken Severed Head]

A point given to the bout of Dracula vs. Nosferatu
A point taken from Blind Dead vs. Gargoyles

The Giant Claw vs. Mothra 3
Daimajin vs. Frankenstein Conquers the World 3
Giant from the Unknown...vs. Tabonga (From Hell it Came) 3
The Phantom of the Paradise vs Dr. Frank-N-Furter 4
The Blind Dead vs Gargoyles 2
Ymir vs. the colossal man (AKA the colossal beast)  5
Gort vs. Martians from War of the Worlds  3
Tarantula Vs. The Giant Mantis 5
The Mole People vs. The Morlocks  3
Godzilla vs. Gamera  4
Dracula vs. Nosferatu  5
The Thing from Another World vs. It the Terror from Beyond Space  4
King Kong vs. The Blob  2
The Abominable Dr. Phibes vs. The Phantom of the Opera  6
Blacula vs. Blackenstein  5

[fmofmpls]

This is going to be a fun game. I'm ready to rumble. BTW, I would love to see that Rob Zombie vs Bob Morris fight! That would make for a great pay per view. Winner takes both polar bears.

A point given to the bout of Tarantula Vs. The Giant Mantis
A point taken from The Phantom of the Paradise vs Dr. Frank-N-Furter (can't stand either character)

The Giant Claw vs. Mothra 3
Daimajin vs. Frankenstein Conquers the World 3
Giant from the Unknown...vs. Tabonga (From Hell it Came) 3
The Phantom of the Paradise vs Dr. Frank-N-Furter 3
The Blind Dead vs Gargoyles 2
Ymir vs. the colossal man (AKA the colossal beast)  5
Gort vs. Martians from War of the Worlds  3
Tarantula Vs. The Giant Mantis 6
The Mole People vs. The Morlocks  3
Godzilla vs. Gamera  4
Dracula vs. Nosferatu  5
The Thing from Another World vs. It the Terror from Beyond Space  4
King Kong vs. The Blob  2
The Abominable Dr. Phibes vs. The Phantom of the Opera  6
Blacula vs. Blackenstein  5